{ "@context": "http://schema.org/", "@type": "Article", "author":"Mark Olsen", "description":"Auditors are identifying fewer critical audit matters in the typical audit report, according to an analysis from the PCAOB. Learn more about the findings.", "image":"https://www.intelligize.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/01/audit-standards-BW-1200.png", "keywords":"critical audit matters, accounting, accounting analytics, Audit Committees, auditing, CAMs, Financial Reporting, PCAOB, sec", "mainEntityOfPage":"Auditors are identifying fewer critical audit matters in the typical audit report, according to an analysis from the Public Company Accounting Oversight Board. At the same time, PCAOB also found that the number of audit reports communicating one CAM has gone up. PCAOB detailed its findings in a report released last month on CAM requirements, which were first implemented in 2020. At the time, the board beefed up its auditing standard to make audit reports more useful to financial statement users. While the standard kept the auditor’s pass/fail opinion in place, it added that auditors should also communicate issues that “relate to accounts or disclosures that are material to the financial statements” and “involved especially challenging, subjective, or complex auditor judgment.” Initially, the Securities and Exchange Commission applied the CAM requirements to so-called large accelerated filers, which include companies with a public float of at least $700 million. The requirements now also apply to companies that don’t qualify as LAFs. The 2020 fiscal year saw an average of 1.69 CAMs communicated per audit report for LAFs. That fell to 1.43 in 2022, representing a decline of about 15% in the two-year period. Nearly two-thirds of audit reports now communicate a single CAM, up from 49%. The average number of critical audit matters per audit report for non-LAFs dipped from 1.23 in 2021 to 1.12 a year later. The PCAOB’s analysis also involved surveying investors to get a better sense of how CAMs are affecting their decision-making. The answer was that investors don’t generally respond to them. Importantly, though, 80% of the investors who looked at CAMs indicated that they helped when it came to sorting out major risks in companies’ financial reporting. (For real-world precedent examples, peer disclosure on non-GAAP methodologies and material weakness, guidance and analytics to support your strategic decision making and financial reporting objectives, CLICK HERE to access Accounting Analytics, new on Intelligize.) “This suggests that investors may still be learning how to find value-relevance in the information content of CAMs, which adds to the total mix of available information investors use in making investment decisions,” the report noted. “Several investors said that they would like auditors to use more specific, rather than generic, language in communicating CAMs and to include in CAMs a discussion of the outcome of audit procedures.” Meanwhile, PCAOB’s research suggested the new auditing standard has had little impact on the auditing process itself. The board found that of their total audit hours, audit engagement teams spent between 1% and 2% of their time addressing CAMs. Additionally, PCAOB determined that there was no evidence that the new standard had impeded communications between auditors and companies’ audit companies or lengthened the audit process. The report pointed out that stakeholders had “raised concerns that the CAM requirements could chill communications between audit committees and auditors” during the rulemaking process for the auditing standard.", "name":"No CAM Do: Fewer Critical Audit Matters Appearing in Reports", "potentialAction":"CLICK HERE to access Accounting Analytics", "url":"https://www.intelligize.com/no-cam-do-fewer-critical-audit-matters-appearing-in-reports/" }
Photograph of skyscrapers with glass windows from the ground facing up to a blue sky

Tag: auditing

5 blocks on a table each with a different icon (from left to right): 3 books, clip-board to-do list, stick figure as a scale, magnifying glass, and a square with gears and a checkmark. Fingers go to pick up the block with the magnifying glass icon

No CAM Do: Fewer Critical Audit Matters Appearing in Reports

5 blocks on a table each with a different icon (from left to right): 3 books, clip-board to-do list, stick figure as a scale, magnifying glass, and a square with gears and a checkmark. Fingers go to pick up the block with the magnifying glass icon

Auditors are identifying fewer critical audit matters in the typical audit report, according to an analysis from the Public Company Accounting Oversight Board. At the same time, PCAOB also found that the number of audit reports communicatin...

Read More

PCAOB Looks to Refresh Quality Control Standard for Accounting Firms

In the sci-fi classic “Terminator 2: Judgment Day,” the film’s heroes find themselves once again on the run from a relentless robotic assassin from the future. In the first sequel to the original “Terminator” film, the new Terminator, dubbe...

Read More
Applicants awaiting interviews, discussing eco disclosures

Help Wanted: ESG Auditors and Consultants

Applicants awaiting interviews, discussing eco disclosures

Now that the Securities and Exchange Commission has proposed rules for disclosing risks related to climate change, publicly traded companies are starting the heavy lifting involved in reporting the newly required environmental, social and g...

Read More
Spiral iron gate railings meeting SOX compliance.

SEC Indicates New Concerns Over Auditor Independence

Spiral iron gate railings meeting SOX compliance.

Who’s watching the watchers? It’s a question that has preoccupied conspiracy theorists and flummoxed polities for centuries. It seems to come up regularly in the world of corporate governance, too, when assessing Wall Street gatekeepers who...

Read More
The Great Wall of China

Auditing Showdown with China Nearing a Conclusion?

The Great Wall of China

Remember the Holding Foreign Companies Accountable Act? Securities and Exchange Commission Chair Gary Gensler warned the world last year that the law, which took effect at the end of 2020, could start causing problems in the United States f...

Read More